I Thought I Was Testing My Father
Updated: Oct 23
By the summer after law school, I knew two things about my father. He was one of the smartest people I had ever known, and I could learn something by listening to him, even when I suspected I wasn’t going to like his answer.
What I had not yet learned was how much he could teach me about a subject I had spent three years studying and he had never studied at all.
My parents had four children and had planned to help each of us through college as best they could. By the time they got to me, circumstances had worked in my favor. My brother Ace had gone to college on a football scholarship. My sister Robi, probably the smartest of us all, spent time at the University of Washington before choosing another path. Trish earned scholarships that carried her through graduate school, all the way to her PhD.
Their paths gave my parents more room to help me. I was fortunate, and I knew it.
I also had some fairly expansive ideas about what I might do with that good fortune.
Pepperdine was high on my list of law schools. I wanted to get back to California. Then I saw the beautiful surroundings, the water, and people water skiing, and I became even more interested in the quality of the education.
I could picture myself there.
I could also picture being discovered as the next Sidney Poitier. Maybe I would be sitting in a coffee shop, talking and making somebody laugh, when somebody in the business would recognize my potential. Actor, comedian, lawyer. At that age, I saw no reason to close off my options.
When Pepperdine offered me a scholarship covering half the tuition, I was proud. I told my brother, and then I told Pop. To me, the scholarship seemed to bring everything within reach.
Pop listened. Then he asked me to consider the rest of the expense.
What would the remaining tuition cost? Where would I live? What would housing cost in that part of California? What would it take to support myself while I was there?
He walked me through it. Even with the scholarship, I could end up spending more to attend Pepperdine than I would at several other schools.
I had been looking at the amount they were offering me. He helped me look at the amount we would still have to pay.
He could have made me feel foolish. Instead, he took my excitement seriously enough to reason with me. That mattered. I could listen without feeling that I had to defend my dignity along with my choice of law school.
He was particularly interested in Georgetown. Eventually, I chose Georgetown, too, and it became an extraordinary experience in my life.
Hollywood would have to wait.
After graduation came the bar exam, and that summer in Atlanta, preparing for it became my job.
I got up around seven each morning and drove to the law library at Georgia State Law School. I studied through the morning, ate lunch in the cafeteria, some times running into Pop, and went back to work. In the evenings, I sat through several more hours of the bar review course being offered nightly at Georgia State. Then I went home, got some sleep, and did it again the next day.
Pop had taught all of us to work steadily. I trusted that. I also understood something about myself: whatever somebody else needed to do to learn a thing, I might need to do twice.
That never embarrassed me. Knowing how I learned gave me something useful to work with. I could spend my time wishing I learned faster, or I could go through the material again.
So I went through it again.
One of my constant companions was a thick book of practice questions. You worked through a set, checked your answers, and studied the explanations.
The book told you why one answer was right and why the others were wrong.
Sometimes I learned more from discovering why my answer was wrong than I did from getting the next one right. There were questions I answered with complete confidence, only to turn to the explanation and realize I had misunderstood what I was being asked.
By the end of the summer, I was getting roughly eighty to eighty-five percent right. I felt good about that. Those scores represented hours of work, and I knew what it had taken to earn them.
Still, the book went everywhere with me.
One Saturday afternoon, Pop and I were riding to get something to eat. He was driving, and I was in the passenger seat studying.
“How hard are those questions?” he asked.
“Pop, these things are hard.”
“Read me one. Let me see how I do.”
Now, I knew my father was brilliant. I had watched him read, teach, and make connections that other people missed for as long as I could remember.
But this was law.
I had just spent three years studying it, followed by most of a summer preparing for this particular test. I thought I had at least a modest advantage.
I started him off gently. I found a question I thought he might be able to answer and read it aloud.
He listened.
“What are the choices?”
I read all four. He thought for a moment, picked one, and I checked the explanation.
He was right.
I smiled. I was pleased for him.
Then I read another question. Again, he asked for the choices. Again, he listened and selected the right answer.
By the third question, being pleased for him was beginning to take some effort.
“Wait a minute, Pop. I’ve been studying this stuff all summer.”
He laughed.
“Well, give me another one.”
I did. He got that one right, too.
At some point, my reasons for reading him questions changed. I had started out wanting to include him in what I was doing. Now I was looking for something that would establish the value of the education I had just completed.
After seven or eight correct answers, he was enjoying himself considerably.
I was proud of my eighty-something percent. He was driving us to lunch and making a hundred.
Then I found a question involving the Rule Against Perpetuities.
This was a rule I had never felt entirely comfortable with, despite having devoted what I considered an unreasonable amount of my life to it.
I read him the question.
“What are the answers?”
I read each choice carefully. Surely, somewhere in this one, my legal education would distinguish itself.
He thought for a moment and gave me his answer.
I checked the book.
Then I looked at him.
“What the hell, Pop?”
He was laughing.
“How are you doing this?”
“I’m just a smart man, Mr. Hilliard.”
He let me sit with that for a while.
We kept going. By the time we finished an entire practice test, he had answered every question correctly. ALL 34 questions. 100 percent!
Every one.
I wanted an explanation.
Eventually, he gave me one.
He told me that he obviously did not know all those rules of law.
What he knew was language. He reminded me that he read constantly, and he had spent a lifetime paying attention to how words worked and how people used them to communicate an idea.
He had been listening to the question, then using everything in the answer choices to help him understand it.
I had thought of those choices as four places to look for the correct answer.
He was examining the relationship among them. One might reveal an assumption in another. A qualification might narrow a statement. A phrase might sound convincing until he compared it with what the question actually asked.
Then there were the words themselves.
Pop understood something about their origins. A term could be unfamiliar, but a root within it might be recognizable. He could use that root to begin working toward its meaning. Then he could compare that possible meaning with the facts in the question and the language of each answer.
He took me through the process. A word in the question had caught his attention. Part of that word suggested a meaning he knew from somewhere else. One answer fit that meaning. Another seemed to fit until he considered a particular phrase. A third made a claim that did not follow from the facts.
He kept moving between the question and the choices, checking one against the other.
I had been waiting for him to recognize a rule I had studied. He had been finding a way into the problem through what he already understood.
As he explained it, I began to appreciate how much was happening behind those few quiet moments before he answered.
He knew how to examine a sentence. He knew that the difference between two words could matter. He knew how to notice a connection, test it, and follow it without getting ahead of what it could actually tell him.
And he read. He read things that had no immediate use, things outside his field, things that interested him simply because there was something there to understand. When an unfamiliar problem arrived, he had a great deal to bring to it.
I sat beside him with the book open in my lap, listening.
The same man who had helped me think through a scholarship was helping me think through the questions in front of me. In both conversations, he had taken the time to show me how he reached an answer.
That was a deliberate part of being his son.
For years, I had watched him ask questions, trace the history of a word, challenge an assumption, or explain why a conclusion did not follow. He wanted me to know how to do those things. He expected that, with practice, I could.
I understood that more clearly sitting beside him that afternoon. I had been his student long before I entered a law school classroom.
And there I was, still asking him how he did it, as though he had not been showing me for years.
I smile now when I remember how determined I became to find a question he would miss. He understood exactly what was happening. He let me search, let me struggle with his perfect score, and enjoyed every minute of it.
But when he explained himself, he gave me his full attention. He wanted me to be able to follow the reasoning and use it for myself.
That is what I carry from that afternoon. I remember the laughter, of course. I can still hear “Mr. Hilliard.” But I also remember the care he took once he began to teach.
I had worked hard that summer. He knew that. I had more work ahead of me, and he was giving me something to help me do it.
The Wisdom of the Heart in this memory has grown clearer as I have grown older. I can still hear Pop laughing, still hear him calling me “Mr. Hilliard” while I searched that book for something he could not answer. I wish I could sit beside him again. I would ask fewer questions to see what he knew and spend more time letting him show me.
He had spent years teaching me how to think, patiently explaining himself because he wanted me to understand how to find my own way. I knew I could trust his mind. He was helping me learn to trust mine.
I thought I was testing my father.
All these years later, when I face something I am not sure I can figure out, I still find myself returning to what he taught me. Sometimes I have to remind myself that I am allowed to begin without knowing the answer. Pop had shown me how to look.
I miss being able to ask him.
I am grateful he spent so much of his life preparing me for the days when I couldn’t.





Comments